A pale gray park bench beneath a live oak beside a curved path and green lawn in a tropical South Florida neighborhood park.

Cutler Bay's Old Pool Closed in February. Legacy Park, Home of the Next One, Broke Ground in October.

The 25-meter pool at Cutler Ridge Park opened in the early 1950s, before the Town of Cutler Bay existed. It closed for good on Friday, February 27, 2026. The park at 10100 SW 200 Street still has its athletic fields, picnic pavilion and covered playground, and it is still home to Albion SC Miami. Its page on the Town's website now marks the pool as "Closed."

On October 23, the Town broke ground on Legacy Park and Municipal Complex off Old Cutler Road. The plans for that campus include a seven-lane pool. The Town closed one pool because it had already planned to build another, and the pace of work on the new campus now decides how long Cutler Bay goes without one.

A water bill of nearly $30,000 a month

The closure decision goes back to September 2022. That month the Town Council hired Stantec Consultants to compare two options: keep the old pool running, or move aquatic programs to the future Legacy Park complex. So the move to a new site was on the table more than three years before the closure.

Underground leaks then pushed the pool's monthly water bills to nearly $30,000. A review team of consultants, engineers, contractors and the Town's aquatics staff found that fixing the leaks and bringing the pool up to 40-year inspection standards would cost about $700,000. Spread over 12 months, the leak-era water bills would have reached about half of that repair estimate. The Town decided that spending $700,000 on a 70-year-old pool, with a modern aquatic center already planned, would not be "a responsible use of taxpayer dollars." Town Manager Rafael Casals called it one of the hardest decisions of his almost 20 years with the Town.

Not everyone agreed. At the February 18 Council meeting, residents urged the Town to delay the closure and look at affordable repairs, and the Vice Mayor asked that the Stantec report go to the Parks & Recreation Advisory Committee and that the closure be delayed, according to Citizen Portal's account of the meeting. The closure went ahead on schedule nine days later.

The building and deck from the 1950s are still standing, and the Town describes the structure as solid. It has said it will keep studying ways to reuse the building and deck for other recreation.

Where the lap lanes are now

The Town's Cutler Ridge Park page lists five nearby pools:

Pool Park Address
Goulds Pool JL (Joe) and Enid W. Demps Park 11350 SW 216 Street
Helen Sands Pool South Dade Park 28151 SW 164th Avenue
West Perrine Pool West Perrine Park 10301 SW 170 Terrace
Tamiami Pool Tamiami Park 11201 SW 24 Street
Ruby George Pool Ruby George Park 201 SW 11th Avenue, Homestead

The list runs from SW 216 Street in Goulds up to SW 24 Street at Tamiami Park and down to Homestead. The Town's Parks & Recreation team takes pool questions at (786) 573-5502.

The pool also served club swimmers. Cutler Ridge Park was home to the Riptides swim and water polo teams. The Miami Riptides pool locations page now lists Gulliver Prep Pool at 6575 N Kendall Drive. The pool planned for Legacy Park is deep enough for water polo, which matters to a town that until this year had a water polo club in its own park.

What is going up on the Potato Field

Legacy Park sits on the parcel locals call the "Potato Field," which was vacant when the Town acquired it. It lies east of Old Cutler Road and north of SW 212th Street, with SW 208th Street on its north edge and SW 92nd Place on its east. The Town acquired the land in a 2020 land swap, trading its former Town Hall building and the property next to it at 10720 Caribbean Boulevard, plus $3 million. Town Hall has stayed at that address in leased space while the new building is designed and built. According to the Town, the swap kept the 16 acres in public use and away from a possible development of more than 480 multifamily units, which also means less traffic on Old Cutler Road.

Twelve of the 16 acres are set aside for park space. The rest holds three buildings:

  • A pool complex with seven swimming lanes, a shallow area and enough depth for water polo.
  • A 12,199-square-foot community center with multipurpose rooms, a dance studio and activity rooms.
  • A three-story, 32,192-square-foot Town Hall with a 146-seat Council Chamber. It will double as an Emergency Operations Center and is being built to withstand Category 5 hurricanes and 175 mph winds.

The Town's announcement also mentions room for walking, farmers' markets, performances and family events. The design team includes Saltz Michelson Architects, Michael Graves, EDSA and Chen Moore, and Kaufman Lynn Construction is the builder.

The pool needed its own bond

Getting the park to this point took two votes. In 2018, voters turned down a $40 million bond. The Town then held more than 23 public meetings, collected over 900 resident comments and worked with the University of Miami School of Architecture on concept plans. In 2022 it asked again, this time for $37 million and with a specific site and plan, and more than 65% of voters approved it.

That $37 million did not cover the pool. To include it, the Town Council approved an additional Capital Improvement Revenue Bond of up to $17 million. The land also needed cleanup first. Arsenic removal from the soil cost more than $12.8 million, paid with federal American Rescue Plan Act money and Town reserves, and the state's Brownfields program awarded the Town more than $1.5 million in Voluntary Cleanup Tax Credits toward that cost. The pool is paid for through that separate revenue bond of up to $17 million, on top of the 2022 voter-approved bond.

The calendar between an empty deck and a new lane line

The Town has said it will open the community center and pool first, ahead of the full campus. Here is the timeline based on the Town's November 3 groundbreaking release and the closure announcement. Dates after this month are Town targets:

  1. February 4, 2026: The Town announces the Cutler Ridge Pool closure.
  2. February 27, 2026: The pool closes.
  3. October 23, 2026: Groundbreaking at Legacy Park.
  4. Now through May 2027: Underground work on stormwater drainage, sewer, water and electrical lines. The Council has already approved the next phase, which covers the buildings, the pool, park improvements and landscaping.
  5. Late 2027 or early 2028: Target opening for the community center and pool.
  6. Summer 2028: Target completion for the full campus.

If those targets hold, Cutler Bay will have gone without a town pool for close to two years, counted from the February 27 closure. As of this week, about eight and a half months of that gap have passed. The pool itself belongs to the building phase that follows the underground work scheduled through May 2027.

Mayor Tim Meerbott spoke at the groundbreaking about how long this will take. "I will not be your Mayor when these doors open, but I will be a proud resident walking through those doors alongside you," he said, according to the Town's release. The Town posts construction updates at cutlerbay-fl.gov/legacypark.

Cutler Ridge Park this winter

Cutler Ridge Park is still in use. On Saturday, December 19, from 5 to 9 p.m., it hosts the Town's Holiday Golf Cart Parade, Toy Drive & Winter Celebration at 10100 SW 200 Street. The event page says more information is coming soon. If you want to swim before then, Goulds Pool at 11350 SW 216 Street is the first pool on the Town's list.

I'll be following the Potato Field as each phase wraps up. If you'd like to know what Legacy Park could mean for your street, or you want a quick update on its timeline, Karina Reyes is happy to talk it through. Let's Connect.

Your Trusted Real Estate Partner

Karina possesses an unparalleled work ethic and commitment to those that she serves. Her philosophy is simple: real estate is based on real relationships. As she gets to know your needs and preferences, she can match you with the best possible home or investment. Additionally, she promises diligence, ease, transparency, and the utmost professionalism as your personal representative in any real estate transaction.

Follow Me on Instagram